How to disagree with your boss and not get fired


Do you disagree with your boss? What happens?

Strong leaders with vision, don’t want to be surrounded by “yes” men and women. They want disruptive thinkers that challenge them and the system. But they do want the organization to benefit.Tweet this  Most bosses, although they rarely say this, would also be happy if the outcome makes them look good too.

What they don’t want, is to be bombarded by show boaters who grandstand for no obvious gain, other than hearing the sound of their own voices, or only wanting personal advancement. So if you dissent with the goals of your boss and organization in mind, your disruption will usually be welcome.

Clarity and certainty

So first of all you need to have clarity and certainty around your intent for disagreeing.Tweet this We’re all going to disagree with our bosses from time to time, and when this takes place, the best thing to do is listen. Your first instinct might be to speak out and up, but in this case, attentive listening is the best and wisest course of action. The adage of asking the right questions to get the right answers, plays well in this scenario.

What are your bosses’ goals and purpose? Tweet this

So if you do disagree, by understanding these points,  you will be doing so from a solid, well thought out base. This will always be well received and perceived to be more respectful.

A good idea in the early stage of the boss/report relationship is to set the scene for disagreement. Maybe even ask how he/she likes to handle dissent at a point when there is none. The onboarding process is frequently a good time do that.Tweet this You can always use that conversation as a point of reference to defuse a potentially tense situation. Some bosses can confuse disagreement with disrespect.

If you need help dealing with situational communication issues check out the 3Plus coaching programs for individuals

Come with a solution

Some years ago I had a young, talented team member who seemed to rail against everything I proposed, but was never really coming up with alternative ideas. Eventually we had something of  a show down. His negativity was also impacting the team. I decided to give him his own project to head up. It was a risk.  When he saw what it was actually like to be a leader and manager, he changed his tune! So giving someone the opportunity to own the outcome and being solution, or alternative driven, is hugely beneficial to their learning curve. When they are in that place, they will become major engaged contributors who will motivate the rest of the team.

There could indeed be times when any differences are too great, perhaps creatively or strategically. Here the best course of action may be to agree to disagree. If the gap is un-bridgeable, the only other route is to move on.

But don’t think this is just about the boss. It’s about you too! Tweet this

This is usually an indicator of lack or research before and during the recruitment process. Interviewing is a two-way street and if you ask the right questions it’s usually possible to get a good feel for the corporate culture and the boss’s management and communication style.

There are many tells in the process. If they are not obvious pose the question “What sort of  input do (can) your team make strategically to ….? ” If the response is “Strategy is defined at board level” you have your answer. If there is a caveat “but we have monthly open team brainstorming sessions” that adds another element.

So never be afraid to disagree with your boss. But make sure you understand what she wants to achieve.

Chameleon bosses

Of course circumstances arise when the boss has been a chameleon and shows her true colours further down the line with her own personal and political agenda. There could issues of ego, defensiveness, bullying and plain old Machiavellian conniving and positioning.

In these cases  you really do need to change your boss. But that’s a different post!

3Plus, Communication, Leadership
Guest Contributor
Email |
3Plus is delighted to publish posts from guest contributers

2 Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Found that interesting? Learn more about our services
Individual services
Make your dreams a reality with a professional evaluation of your career to date.
more info
Corporate services
The evidence is in. More women in your company can deliver 35% greater financial returns. (Catalyst)
more info
Upcoming events
Currently we don't have upcoming events
Download and listen free podcasts
How to get Noticed by Head Hunters and Recruiters
Free Download

In this power coaching podcast, we’re going to tackle one of the questions asked multiple times a week by active job seekers and passive candidates.

How can I get noticed by head hunters and recruiters and connect with them?

In this short power coaching podcast Dorothy Dalton shares some tips and tricks to make sure that you are always on the radar of the recruitment and search specialists who can be most helpful to you. With extensive experience in executive search and corporate HR Dorothy has placed, coached and trained thousands of men and women to career success. As a career coach she has a deep understanding of the job search market and what job seekers need to do to position themselves to they are easily found.

As CEO of 3Plus she also has deep experience of the challenges women face in the workplace. Sadly because women tend not to create career strategies they can be vulnerable when it comes to dealing with change. Regular transitions become career crises. In this short session you will learn some simple tips and tricks to make sure you are on the radar of key recruitment specialists in your sector, geography or function.  It’s not rocket science.





One of the most puzzling things about working in executive search is that people and I say this reluctantly particularly women fail to plan ahead. You’ve heard me say before that only 5% of women have a career strategy. This means that they are not prepared for any emergencies until they become a crisis.


Goal setting tips to boost your career
Free Download

The happiest people are those that really love their jobs. Those that don’t, dread Sunday nights and the upcoming work week. So how do you get to a place where you look forward to a new week of doing what satisfies you? You’ll have to either learn to love your current role, or make a commitment to pursue your dream job. Use these goal setting tips to help you get to where you want to be.

Some women choose the latter, and to do so you’ll have to set career goals to get where you want to be. So make sure you have a detailed plan on how to land a job that you will tick all the boxes.

The majority of women choose to stay in their own organizations and even then you still need to have goals, not just KPis set by your manager. But even if you do see your career developing within your current business it’s still important to set goals.

Many women struggle with career planning and creating a career strategy which can lead to problems. This makes them vulnerable to and sort of challenge which can moprh into a full blown career crisis. Some simple steps to plan and prepare can help avoid this.

Take a look at these goal setting tips to help boost your career and set you on the right path.

Lewis Carroll  said

If you don’t know where you are going any road will get you there.”

Research shows that only about 5% of women create career goals and a career strategy. This can have a negative impact on your career progression. It means you are reactive not proactive and career glitches can morph into full blown crises. It puts women at a clear disadvantage to men.

Learn these simple goal setting tips to boost your career and protect and prepare you for all eventualities. If these goal setting tips make you think that you could use some further help,  contact us immediately.


When Does Female Rivalry Turn into Sabotage
Free Download

There’s a lot of stuff written on social media about  female rivalry and competition between women. Some of it makes sense and some of it is confusing. Organizations are pyramids with fewer roles at the top than at the bottom. It is inevitable that at some level, as more and more women are in the talent pipeline, at some point they will be in competition with other women.

Many would say that women aren’t competitive. I would suggest re-framing that. I think it’s more accurate to say they are not as competitive in the workplace as men. We have also been made to feel guilty about being competitive. We need to get over that.  Here are the reasons:

  1. The male nature of corporate culture makes it a disincentive to compete
  2. Women don’t want to compete because  prescribed male goals are not attractive enough for them. “Work 14 hour days, not see my partner or family … get sick.. thanks.. I’ll pass”
  3. Women don’t know how to compete in the workplace. They are new arrivals on the corporate competition scene and lack practise.
  4. Women experience gender blow back when they do compete, from both men and women
  5. Women have been raised to think that competing with other women is not empowering them. As more women enter the talent pipeline that is just nonsense.

Learn some insights from Annabel Kaye, Employment Law Expert about how it’s OK to be competitive and the danger zone when it can turn into sabotage. Understand the benefits of mutual support and how all women can profit from having strong strategic allies, role models and mentors.






The importance of Hard Talk
Free Download

Dawn Metcalfe, author of Managing the Matrix and Hard Talk, shares with us  tips to achieve the lasting communication skills needed to tackle the difficult conversations we encounter in the workplace. Hard Talk answers the big questions like:

  • How do I manage a boss who insists on micro-managing me?
  • How do I let a high performer know that they are not getting the promotion he wants?
  • What can I do about a direct report who doesn’t show me respect?
  • How do I tell my boss that despite all efforts our deadline on an important deliverable will be missed?

In this podcast, Dawn Metcalfe will give us an overview to handle challenging scenarios to empower you with the skills needed to ensure you have these conversations in the best way and generate the best outcome. Make your workplace and your professional experience more fruitful and less fraught by learning the importance of Hard Talk.