The minefield of feedback for women
How to ensure feedback for women is accurate and consistent
Constructive input is essential for career development, so let's start encouraging it. So why is feedback for women so erratic?
Women and feedback are two words which send out alarm signals. A process that is completely routine for their male colleagues, either on a daily and informal basis or more formally, becomes a minefield for their female colleagues. In theory, feedback allows you to take into consideration someone else's experience of something you have done or said. Feedback can include specific critiques and messages from others, both positive and negative. Feedback allows you to adjust your performance, behaviour or strategy in a constructive way. It leads to better outcomes which are career enhancing. It also gives you data from which you can make your own observations and learnings. This can be difficult, especially if we don't have an anchored sense of self, which is derived in part from the input of others. Feedback for women continues to be non-existent, stereotyped or unclear.
Lack of feedback means that you are operating in a vacuum. Misleading, biased or incorrect input can be even more confusing.
Gender gap for women and feedback
Many women I've worked with over the years say repeatedly that the feedback they are given by their managers or colleagues is often misleading or even contradictory. They can't establish what they need to do to put things right. Feedback for women continues to be a maze to be navigated with caution. Deciphering the sub-text, guessing what's missing or trying to match the vocabulary with self-perception or tangible performance is a massive challenge.
A study from The Center for Talent Innovation suggests:
- Women are 32% less likely to receive any feedback from male superiors.
- 81% percent of women say that feedback is so contradictory, they don't know how to respond.
Other studies show that women's self-evaluations are consistently harsher than their bosses' feedback. Women also have a tendency to personalise criticism.
Do you tend to personalise criticism? Try our Returner Roll-Up Session to help you Develop Resilience.
Women frequently receive softer feedback from male bosses and peers because benevolent sexism kicks in. This is a misguided effort to protect the "gentle" feelings of their female direct reports. However, withholding accurate input deprives women of a key channel for constructive input to strengthen their leadership or skill-based capabilities and improve. Men also receive informal insights into their performance on a more frequent basis. This gives them an inbuilt added advantage.
Feedback is a vehicle for facilitating self-improvement. Lack of it can hold women back. To compensate, individual women will have to learn to be direct and ask for specifics and more precise language. This can be challenging.
Frequently they are told: "Just keep on doing what you're doing," which isn't productive. Asking for a detailed breakdown and concrete examples of what that could entail is vital to help improve performance.
Women often receive different styles of feedback compared to their male colleagues, in terms of the language used and the areas specified. One way to address this is by achieving greater objectivity in evaluations. This ensures fairness in the way feedback is given and performance is assessed. Ask for facts and data. Any criteria should be explicit. Crucially evaluation processes should be designed to flag up and limit the influence of decision makers’ conscious and unconscious biases.
What can you look for as an individual manager or HR professional?
- Do your performance evaluations show consistently higher ratings for men than for women or other groups?
- Do performance ratings for women shift at certain milestones (when they have had children, taken parental leave or opted for a different work pattern?)
- Are men promoted more readily than women, and on what basis?
If you are described as "edgy" or "emotional," or "too much," insist on specific instances, preferably that someone else witnessed.
Women should be clear about which areas of their professional lives require further, or more precise, feedback. They also need to be clear about what they should ignore or let go totally. If you have any doubt, ask for input from multiple sources.
Above all put yourself in a place where you are open and ask for feedback on a regular basis, from both bosses and peers. See what a difference it makes.
Encourage people in your workplace to think about and identify their biases to minimise discrimination with our Unconscious Bias Training Workshops.
Found that interesting?
Learn more about our services
Make your dreams a reality with a professional evaluation of your career to date.
The evidence is in. More women in your company can deliver 35% greater financial returns. (Catalyst)
Dates for the Diary
November 12th European Commission DG GROW
Informal talk on how to deal with sexism - 12.30 - 1400
November 25th Council of the European Union - Corporate Event
How to deal with sexism and harassment in the workplace
Download and listen free podcasts
How to Create an Effective USP What is a USP? Our Unique Selling Point or UVP (Unique Value Proposition) is our key core message about where...read more
How to Rethink the Modern Workplace for Gender Equality New research shows that diversity and inclusion is a top priority for leaders. So why...read more
Menopause in the workplace In this podcast with Nicki Williams award winning author, keynote speaker and Founder of Happy Hormones for Life,...read more
How to Cultivate Empathy in the Workplace Nancy Milton, international business communications expert, keynote speaker and author, share some vital...read more
Taking Care of your COW Tanvi Guatam, international Personal Branding expert says there is a misconception out there that a personal brand is...read more
The importance of Hard Talk Dawn Metcalfe, author of Managing the Matrix and Hard Talk, shares with us tips to achieve the lasting communication...read more
When Does Female Rivalry Turn into Sabotage There’s a lot of stuff written on social media about female rivalry and competition between women. Some...read more
Goal setting tips to boost your career The happiest people are those that really love their jobs. Those that don’t, dread Sunday nights and...read more
Sexism: How to stage a Bystander Intervention in the Workplace In this power coaching podcast, we're going to tackle one of the questions...read more
How to Get Noticed by Head Hunters & Recruiters In this power coaching podcast, we're going to tackle one of the questions asked multiple...read more
It might not be apparently obvious how a consensual relationship can turn someone into a poor brand ambassador, but we need to take into account the power structures at play.read more
We tend to think of single-sex education as being an antiquated notion, but maybe it could solve some of our more contemporary issues.read more
Violence against female politicians is an intimidation tactic, and it’s working. We need to stop this trend before it gets worse.read more