Does the corporate world “masculate” women?

Why does the workplace masculate women?


Does the corporate world masculate women?

The first time my former boss and dear friend Suzanne Villeneuve saw me at work she thought I was Lady Godiva. No, I wasn’t riding a horse naked down the hall protesting corporate taxation, but I had long wavy blonde hair and was wearing a pastel blue suit with a long fitted skirt and a bolero jacket with a white frilly blouse that spilled out of my jacket like a salad of Boston Bibb lettuce. I was, in a word, unabashedly feminine. That’s two words but everybody knows that women are wordy.

Fast forward fifteen years to my final year in the corporate world. Lady Godiva had disappeared. My long locks were shorn to a splash-and-dash cut, my pastels were victims of a hostile takeover by fifty shades of banker, and my curves and frills had been replaced by straight lines and sharp angles.

Read: Make-up or not? Authenticity or compliance?

Disgarding femininity

What happened? Why did I discard virtually every vestige of femininity? Nobody told me the corporate environment was a no-frills zone. Nobody said there was a ban on pastel colours. Nobody said it wasn’t okay to look and act feminine. But I sensed it. I sensed it when my boss (not Suzanne) took my direct report to a strip club for a birthday-suit lunch. I knew I didn’t want to look anything like what they saw on stage. I sensed it when I looked around and saw successful women who looked and behaved like one of the guys.

So slowly I changed. I knew I had the uniform right when I spied a successful colleague (she had reached the blue chip director level in finance) who was wearing exactly the same outfit as me–black dress pants, black pumps and a black blouse with little yellow specks that on a black backdrop no longer looked like jaunty polka dots, but stark data points on a scatter diagram.

Read: Taking a look at your comfort zone

My curves turned into angles shortly after the company moved to a new location that featured a state-of-the-art fitness centre. My next-door neighbour marched to the gym each lunch hour in her navy blue suit and sensible shoes, gym bag in hand and a fiercely determined look on her face. I resisted her example and the pull of the rowing machine until I saw Linda Hamilton in Terminator 2: Judgment Day.

I wanted Linda’s muscular machine-gun-toting arms. I thought that being able to arm wrestle my colleagues might give me a competitive advantage if the selection process ever began to resemble an NFL combine. So I started working out. The day Lady Godiva died was the day I looked in the mirror and saw deltoidsTweet this. A colleague said that my direct report who could have played professional hockey and I were the top corporate jocks.

Hooray. My sex change was complete.

Masculine women

A Stanford study backs up my empirical observations. Masculine women–providing they can turn off the testosterone and play nice when necessary–receive 1.5 times more promotions than feminine women or masculine men and 2 times as many promotions as feminine men.

“There is no evidence that ‘acting like a lady’ does anything except make women more well liked.”(Olivia O’Neill PhD co-author of Stanford Study)

Many of you will read the above quote and say “Duh”. Of course frilly frou frou won’t get you anywhere in the corporate world. But who decided frilly frou frou was wrong?Tweet this What if men had to strategically behave like women to get ahead–act like women most of the time, but when it’s time to roll out the spreadsheets act like men? What a bizarre notion.

We wring our hands and wonder why women leave the corporate world in droves when the reason is in plain sight. The only way women can succeed in the corporate world is to behave like men except when it’s best to behave like women. The workplace masculates successful women.  Many women either can’t play gender chess or refuse to override their feminine tendencies so they “leave Dodge” as Sallie Krawcheck so succinctly put it.

I left Dodge. Since then my long locks have grown back and my closet looks like a cotton candy explosion of frilly frou frou, but I haven’t lost the sharp angles. The experience has made me stronger…

Read: 6 Daily habits to boost your confidence

This post was originally posted on LinkedIn Pulse 24th February 2015


Many people don’t start thinking about their careers until there is a problem. So take a few moments when you are relaxed, to understand what is important to you.  Have our Career Reflections Worksheets delivered right into your in-box.  Print them out in the old school way or keep them open on your phone. Use them as a guide to give your thoughts some structure.

Invest some time in yourself! Don’t wait until it’s too late!

[contact-form-7 404 "Not Found"]
3Plus, Board Room Image, Career, Conversations about leadership, Leadership, Personal & Professional Development
Web | Email | Twitter | LinkedIn
Lynne is a writer with a cheeky streak. A former Globe and Mail Careers columnist and a published author of two books--Emails from the Edge nominated for the Stephen Leacock Award for Humour (Insomniac Press, 2006) and Drink Wine and Giggle (The Fig and the Vine, 2013). Certified as a personal trainer, she believes in the joy of sweat, and that fitness gives you a mental edge that makes you better at everything you do outside the gym.

Leave a Reply

Found that interesting? Learn more about our services
Individual services
Make your dreams a reality with a professional evaluation of your career to date.
more info
Corporate services
The evidence is in. More women in your company can deliver 35% greater financial returns. (Catalyst)
more info
Upcoming events
Currently we don't have upcoming events
Download and listen free podcasts
When Does Female Rivalry Turn into Sabotage
Free Download

The importance of Hard Talk
Free Download

Taking Care of your COW
Free Download

How to Cultivate Empathy in the Workplace
Free Download