How women fall into the likeability trap

Why do powerful women get caught in the likeability trap?

Powerful men are likeable, powerful women are not. Why do women have to balance success and personality? How do we avoid the double bind of the likeability trap?

Nice girls finish last. Successful women are seen as less likeable, and likeable women are seen as less successful.  For men, the opposite correlation is true: powerful men tend to be better liked.  This phenomenon is known as the likeability trap for women, and it’s a huge hurdle for powerful women to overcome.

Sheryl Sandberg’s Lean In first popularised the idea of the likeability trap, but the idea really started to hit home during the 2016 US election.

likeability trap

When women are decisive they are bossy

Hillary Clinton was a thoroughly competent Secretary of State. Towards the end of the Obama administration, she had higher approval ratings than the then-president himself.  In the run-up to the election, Trump didn’t bother to criticise her past political decisions.  Instead, his campaign was largely focused on the fact that she was bossy and abrasive, with a straying husband and cold eyes.  She wasn’t accused of being incompetent, ill-informed, or unreliable.  She was just a nasty woman.

Read: 18 Things Respected Well-Liked Leaders Consistently Do

The backlash comes because the very qualities people need to succeed in the workplace – such as being forthright, decisive, and authoritative – are seen as traditionally male attributes.  When a woman strives for a promotion or fires a bad employee, she is deviating from the social script which dictates how a woman is expected to be.

Networking and building personal relationships are far more important at the top of the pile than the bottom, which means that the likeability trap tends to affect women more as they advance in their careers.  The higher someone is in the company hierarchy, the more likely they are to be criticised on the style of their leadership rather than their performance.  So not only are successful women seen as less likeable due to their gender, they’re also more likely to face criticism of their character due to their high position.

Read: Pink in politics. Powerful or pandering? 

The gender penalty

Under Jill Abramson, its first female executive editor, the New York Times garnered eight Pulitzer Prizes in three years.  It wasn’t enough to save Abramson for being fired in 2014 for her “blunt and confrontational” management style; previous men in the role were known for throwing telephones across the newsroom in screaming rages, but never faced the same criticism.

Not all leadership styles evoke equal hostility.  Research has shown that male and female leaders are seen as equally likeable when acting in a way that invites participation, for example when asking for employees’ suggestions.  But when it comes to authoritative acts – like imposing an unpopular new system – then female managers lose popularity in a way that male managers don’t.

Read: The power of potential within…

There are ways that women can make themselves seem more likable at work, through tricks like using more eye contact and always calling people by their name.  But why should we have to?  It’s not our responsibility to make ourselves smaller to match society’s expectations.

Looking to build your female talent pipeline? Contact 3Plus now!

3Plus, 3Plus online e-Gazine for professional women, Board Room Image, Conversations about leadership, Culture, Gender Balance, Leadership, Personal & Professional Development, Women who Inspire
Alice Bell
Email | Google+ |
"Alice writes online about business, popular science, and women's lifestyle. After a few years working her way around the world, she has settled in the north of England and taken a day job as a maths teacher. Her life's ambition is to earn enough money to start repaying her student debt."

Leave a Reply

Upcoming events
How become a good team player
2017-09-28 @ 1:00 PM - 1:30 PM
From the comfort of your home, ,
How to shine in a new job
2017-10-12 @ 1.00PM - 2.00PM
From the comfort of your home, ,
Download and listen free podcasts
When Does Female Rivalry Turn into Sabotage
Free Download

The importance of Hard Talk
Free Download

Taking Care of your COW
Free Download

How to Cultivate Empathy in the Workplace
Free Download

Found that interesting? Learn more about our services
Individual services
Make your dreams a reality with a professional evaluation of your career to date.
more info
Corporate services
The evidence is in. More women in your company can deliver 35% greater financial returns. (Catalyst)
more info