The Career Strategy Gap

Published on: March 22, 2026

By:

The Career Strategy Gap

We want to check what’s going on today with women and career strategies

 

Some Background

Before you read on take our 2026 Career Strategy survey.  LINK HERE 

A decade ago, if you asked a group of professional women  ( and we did) whether they had a clear career strategy, the answer was predictable,  and a little sobering. In 2014, research from 3Plus International found that only around 5% of women could describe a concrete, structured career plan compared to 85% of men. This study focused on the MBA community

The vast majority were doing what women have been conditioned to do for generations: working hard, being reliable, delivering results, and hoping that someone would notice.

From 5% to 50%,  and Back Again

Between 2014 and 2019, the conversation around women’s career development changed dramatically. Lean In had entered the lexicon. The #MeToo movement had made systemic barriers visible and impossible to ignore. A new wave of women-in-leadership programmes, mentoring circles, and career coaching services proliferated. And the numbers reflected it: 3Plus research carried out in 2020 found that although over 90% of Millennial women set career goals, only 50% created a career strategy,  a landmark improvement on 2014, but still a tale of two halves.

 

That caveat, vague goals  (get promoted, be happy) and no strategy, is crucial. It’s the difference between knowing you want to reach a destination and actually planning your route, your equipment, your contingencies. You can want something very much and still have no real plan to get there.

Then COVID-19 arrived, and the progress largely unravelled. During lockdown, women took on 31 hours of housework and childcare per week compared to 9.75 hours for their male partners, and women dropped out of the workforce at alarming rates, overwhelmed by the demands placed upon them. For millions of women, the luxury of thinking five years ahead was replaced by the urgency of surviving the week. Post-pandemic, many women found themselves lost and without purpose , a professional identity crisis that went far beyond the numbers on a strategy spreadsheet.

Why the Gap Has Always Existed

The 3Plus data is striking, but it doesn’t emerge from a vacuum but reflects patterns that career researchers have been documenting for decades.

A 3Plus research project in the international MBA community, conducted with Megan Jones, found that both men and women identified career strategy and planning as one of the two main barriers to career success for professional women. Men placed career planning in the top spot; women placed it second,  behind negotiation. The uncomfortable implication: although women MBA graduates can explain corporate capital budgeting and business strategy in exhaustive detail, they don’t seem to be applying those principles to themselves.

Further 3Plus research found that only 16% of women had a clear short-to-mid-term career plan, compared to 83% of their male colleagues,  a yawning gap at precisely the career stage where strategic choices compound.

Without a strategy, women are essentially navigating an obstacle course blindfolded, relying on performance alone to carry them through,  and the evidence is clear that performance alone is not enough.

Cost Of No Strategy

What the research does confirm is that women tend to be more selective in their applications,  and when they do apply, they are more likely to be hired than men applying for the same role. This is not a confidence gap but a different and often more strategic reading of the hiring process, one that the system does not reward transparently.

The cumulative effect of these structural barriers is nonetheless measurable. Women remain underrepresented at every level of the corporate pipeline,  especially in senior leadership, where they make up just 29% of C-suite roles. The largest drop-off occurs at the first promotion from entry level to manager.

People are seeing what they are calling an ambition gap but that phrase is a trap,  because it’s a support gap NOT an ambition gap. Women are still doing the bulk of invisible work and when they receive the same career support that men do, this gap falls away entirely. The ambition is not absent,  it is simply unsupported.

Setting the Record Straight on Self-Selection

The much-repeated claim that men apply when 60% qualified and women only when 100% ready has no verifiable data behind it. Researcher Curt Rice traced it to a single anecdote from a Hewlett Packard executive, subsequently amplified without scrutiny by McKinsey and Sheryl Sandberg’s Lean In. There was never a study and no methodology to examine and that myth has been debunked. 

The Behavioural Insights Team conducted the first rigorous empirical test in 2022. What they found:

Men apply when around 52% qualified. Women apply at around 56% qualified.

Critically, this small gap disappears entirely among more qualified candidates. The real barrier is not a dramatic confidence deficit in women, it is a combination of male-coded hiring processes, inflated job specifications, and women correctly perceiving that the rules of recruitment are opaque and rarely explained.

 

Upsides To Serendipity

It would be too simplistic to frame this purely as a lack of individual discipline. Women’s relationship to career planning is shaped by structural realities and social conditioning that deserve more than a ‘just make a plan’ response.

1. Women are taught to be responsive, not directive

Social role expectations push women toward communal, relational orientations. Research shows women tend to seek occupations focused on social interaction and communal values, while men strive for occupations characterised by high status and competition. A career strategy is a directive act,  it requires women to put themselves first in a way that runs counter to much of their socialisation.

2. They are other-centred

Most women are other-centred and tend to focus their energy on other people, frequently putting their own needs last — especially when factoring in the requirements of partners and children. Career strategy requires a degree of self-focus that can feel almost transgressive.

3. They may expect merit to be rewarded automatically

The belief that good work speaks for itself is not naive;  it’s the implicit contract many women were sold during their education. Research by Benson et al. found that women are more likely to be perceived as having lower potential than men, despite having higher actual performance ratings. Without a strategy, there is no mechanism to correct this bias.

There is a legitimate argument that excessive rigidity in career planning can close down opportunities that couldn’t have been predicted. Serendipity and adaptability are genuine career assets , but there is a meaningful distinction between strategic flexibility and the absence of any direction at all.

Hope, as a career strategy, has a poor track record.

4. They don’t put a price tag on their goals

Many women know what they want. They want a comfortable home, good schools for their kids, travel and holidays, a social life, savings for a rainy day, hobbies and maybe support their parents. But all of these things need a price tag something they quite often fail to do.

The Post-COVID Reset: A Warning Signal

The COVID-induced collapse in career strategy behaviours among women is not merely a statistical blip. Only half of companies are now prioritising women’s career advancement, part of a several-year trend in declining commitment to gender diversity. Some have already scaled back programmes beneficial to women,  remote work, formal sponsorship, and targeted career development.

Society expects women not only to fulfil the role of caregivers at home but also to maintain competitiveness in the workplace. When women struggle to balance these demands, their career development is the first thing to suffer.

What Needs to Change in 2026

The data arc,  5% in 2014, 50% in 2019, single digits post-COVID,  tells a story that is mostly about conditions, not  competence or commitment. When conditions are supportive, women invest in their career strategies. When conditions collapse, so does the investment. The solution requires:

  • Organisations recommitting to structural support,  sponsorship programmes, flexible advancement pathways, and career development investment that doesn’t evaporate in a crisis.
  • Women recognising that career strategy is not selfish,  it is the foundation of financial independence, resilience, and the ability to weather uncertainty. Strategies are not set in stone – they can also be reconfigured.
  • Partners having honest, joint career conversations,  most couples don’t have a shared career strategy, and women too often adapt around an unspoken male career trajectory. It’s really important to discuss these openly as a couple – if you are in a partnership and even with your kids especially teenagers.
  • A redefinition of what career strategy looks like for women, not a rigid corporate ladder blueprint, but a living document of goals, development priorities, and key conversations.

For companies that lost focus in recent years, 2026 should be the year of recommitting to women in the workplace. The same is true for women themselves.

We want to check what’s going on today with women and career strategies  – take our 2026 survey and circulate in your networks.  LINK HERE  


    Written by

    Dorothy Dalton
    Dorothy Dalton
    Dorothy Dalton is Founder of 3Plus International a specialist HR consulting organisation focusing on designing inclusive workplaces. She supports organizations to achieve business success and individuals to reach their potential. She is CIPD qualified, a Certified Trainer and multi-disciplinary Coach, including Trauma Informed Practices. She is a Certified ISO 45003 Practitioner (Psychosocial Safety)

    Related Posts

    Will the EU AI Act Make Recruitment More Equitable?

    Will the EU AI Act Make Recruitment More Equitable?

    AI regulation, recruitment bias, and the challenging question of whether financial penalties will change corporate behaviour.  The EU AI Act is supposed to make artificial intelligence safer, more transparent and more accountable, and I have great faith in it although

    Published on: November 4, 2026

    Career Confidence Is Not the Whole Story

    Career Confidence Is Not the Whole Story

    What our 2026 Career Strategy & Planning Survey tells us about confidence, barriers, and the questions we still need to ask When we launched the 3Plus International Career Strategy & Planning Survey, we wanted to understand how people approach their

    Published on: October 21, 2026

    LinkedIn, Harassment and the EU Digital Services Act

    LinkedIn, Harassment and the EU Digital Services Act

     What Five Transparency Reports Reveal LinkedIn presents itself as a professional networking platform, yet many members especially women report being subjected to sexual ahrassment and bullying. How well does it protect users from these behaviours, and how consistently does it

    Published on: October 17, 2026