It is time to rename the maternal wall?
The maternal wall exists for women, but we need to rename it as a family wall, or better yet have no walls at all.
The maternal wall is a term referring to stereotypes and various forms of discrimination encountered by “working mothers” and “mothers seeking employment. ” That language alone is outdated. We after all never talk about “working fathers,” or “fathers seeking employment.” After many years of trying to make changes to that situation, I wonder if like taking a hand bag to a knife fight, we are going about this the wrong way and we need to come at things differently.
The maternal wall exists because of the level of discrimination and bias that women experience in the workplace due to assumptions that they are less committed or competent because of their care giving responsibilities. We need to break down down the practices associated with that maternal wall, but also to actively working to challenge and overcome these biases to create a more equitable and inclusive work environment for all.
Reproductive organs
Women hit the maternal wall and workplace discrimination because they have a uterus. It is all centred on their ability to bear children. This might be the kids they currently have, they had in the past, or might choose to have in the future. They may not even want children, which an increasing number of women are choosing, or may not even be able to have them ever, or they may be past child bearing age.
But it is their type of reproductive organs which is held against them. Men are not discriminated against because they have a penis with the potential to impregnate women what could be thousands of women.
Stereotypes and bias
Women are also penalised because of the expectation that they will take care of said offspring. Even today in many cultures there is a strong belief that a woman should assume the role of caregiver. Research from Pew in 2016 suggests that in the U.S. “Among those who think children are better off with a parent at home, about 53% say it doesn’t matter which one stays home, while 45% say it’s better if the mother is the parent who isn’t employed outside the home. Just 2% say it’s better if the father is the parent who stays home.
In two-parent households “men are more likely to suggest that children are are better off when a parent stays home (63% vs. 55%). But among those who think a parent should stay home, roughly similar shares of men (46%) and women (43%.)”
In the E.U. 100 million people care for children younger than 15 years and/or incapacitated (ill, elderly and/or disabled) relatives of 15 years and older.
Parenting Penalties
When women try to adjust their work schedules to accommodate child care issues they experience push back and/or are sidelined. But then so are men. If it’s a one-off rush-to-the-school-concert in between meetings kind of thing, then there is a tendency to think of it as “cute” and “caring.” But if men want an ongoing and regular commitment to parenting, they also pay a penalty.
Men who want to take parenting leave report that their managers and colleagues actively try to discourage them. 76% of fathers will return to work in less than a week after welcoming a new child. The length of parenting leave men get is highly inadequate and embeds even further the burden of childcare on women. In the U.S. there is no paid parenting leave for men.

But for women there is an additional layer of discrimination against in the following ways which men experience to a lesser extend, even those with caring responsibilities:
- Women are denied stretch assignments and key projects
- Managers question their competency and reliability
- They experience demotions or career set backs when they return from maternity leave.
- They are paid less
- They are given non-actionable feed back
- They lack sponsors
Why there should be no walls at all
1. Equal parenting leave
“Give us a world where half our homes are run by men, and half our institutions are run by women. I’m pretty sure that would be a better world.” Sheryl Sandberg
If working fathers take parental leave, we can challenge the notion that men are the breadwinners and women are carers. It will level the playing field both in the office and at home. Organisations have to support “working fathers” and encourage them to take their full parental leave allowance to normalise child caring and raising responsibilities as “parental” responsibilities. This will reduce the career limiting biases that women experience in the workplace around reliability, mobility and competence.
2. Manage biases
Employers should train their employees, especially leaders, managers and HR, to recognise and mitigate against the unconscious biases that contribute to the building of the maternal or even family wall. This should be an ongoing activity not a box checking workshop which contributes to gender washing and diversity dishonesty.
3. Presence culture
Employers should focus on results rather than presence to measure performance and offer flexible work arrangements, such as hybrid, remote work, job-sharing, with flexible hours, to accommodate the needs of all working parents.
4. Career development opportunities
Employers can provide career development opportunities, with a formal sponsorship tree in place, and not leave the development of women to their already over- burdened women executives. They need mentoring programmes and leadership training, to make sure that women are not penalised for having a uterus.
We need to stop thinking of this as a maternal wall. In reality, it’s a family wall. In a time of declining and ageing populations and chronic skill set shortages there should be no walls at all. It’s an outdated concept and any biases need to be firmly managed and the practices related to it need to stop.
Make sure that your company is creating an inclusive workplace for everyone, with 3Plus’ Unconscious Bias Training Workshop.





